News from the Revolutionary Association of the Women of Afghanistan (RAWA)
RAWA News
News from the Revolutionary Association of the Women of Afghanistan (RAWA)
RAWA News


 

 

 





 


 


Help RAWA: Order from our wish list on Amazon.com

RAWA Channel on Youtube

Follow RAWA on Twitter

Join RAWA on Facebook



IWPR, January 8, 2011

Afghans Unconvinced by Karzai Presidency

Straw poll suggests most Kabulis disappointed by Hamid Karzai after nearly a decade of his rule

By Khan Mohammad Danishju

Nine years after Hamid Karzai came to power, Afghans have some harsh things to say about his performance. While some argue that his apparent shifts in position are the mark of an astute politician negotiating his way through difficult times, others say some of the compromises he has made have been disastrous for Afghanistan.

Karzai in Bonn Conference
President Karzai attending a NATO summit on Afghanistan, November 2010. (Photo: UN Photo/Evan Schneider)

IWPR interviewed more than 100 Kabul residents from various walks of life on their perception of the Afghan president, who was appointed head of an interim Afghan administration at the December 2001 Bonn conference which shaped the contours of the post-Taleban era. He was elected president twice, in 2004 and then in 2009.

Alami Balkhi, a member of Afghan parliament elected in September, sees Karzai as a clever tactician whose diplomatic approach has kept a diversity of forces, domestic and external, on side during a period of ongoing crisis.

Balkhi he acknowledged that to achieve this, the president “sometimes shifts his position and views, so as to make peace and accommodate popular sensitivities”.

As a result, Balkhi said, Karzai had succeeded in smoothing relations with Afghanistan’s neighbours and with western states. This had allowed him to simultaneously build relationships with and secure assistance from rivals like the United States, Iran and Russia.

But for many other Afghans, this flexibility has gone way too far at times.

“I believe Karzai is like a circus artiste – on the one hand, seeking favour with those who dislike the Americans while also telling the Americans behind closed doors not to get upset as he’s just playing tricks on the others,” Murtazah, a 47-year-old resident of Kabul’s Chahardai district, said.

“Karzai is good at… dodging the big issues both in public and in private,” Murtazah continued. “He talks as though everything were fine. To achieve his aims, he’s always struck deals with powerful individuals and called it compromise. That’s why he is popularly known as the ‘deal-maker’.”

Another resident of the capital, Shah Mohammad, 48, added, “There are two kinds of compromise – the healthy kind and the unhealthy. Karzai’s kind is the negative, unhealthy compromise.”

In Shah Mohammad’s view, Karzai has recruited and worked with too many Afghan politicians who were implicated in past conflict and abuses, and has failed to uphold rule of law, security and justice.

“Such negative compromises have driven the country further into profound crisis,” Shah Mohammad concluded.

Another interviewee, 27-year-old Ahmad Murid, agreed that Karzai had become too closely involved with problematic figures whom he described as “criminals”.

“Over the last decade, I haven’t been able to discern this man’s true face, but the one thing that sticks in my mind about him is that his resolve is weak,” Murid said. “Sometimes he laughs, sometimes he cries. He may call someone a traitor and then describe the same person as a brother and patriot.”

Others believe that in reality, President Karzai has little say in Afghan politics and is at the mercy of bigger interests.

“Sometimes may Karzai thinks he’s the decision-maker, but there are other forces at play here which pressure him into changes of position,” Humayrah Haqmal, a lecturer in the Law and Political Science department at Kabul university, said.

Hakim Asher, head of the Government Media and Information Centre, rejected all the allegations commonly made against the president, saying he had never done deals with criminals and had consistently acted for the good of the nation.

The need to make reasonable compromises was part and parcel of the president’s job; current circumstances required him to “work with certain forces” in the “national and international interest”, Asher said.

He argued that victories in two presidential elections showed high levels of public support for Karzai.

Although Karzai was challenged by a range of candidates in the two elections, none of those interviewed named an obvious alternative.

“It’s true I did vote for Mr Karzai twice,” Kabul schoolteacher Nafisah said. “Among worse candidates, he was just bad, so I went for bad.”

Khan Mohammad Danishju is an IWPR-trained reporter in Afghanistan.

Published on Jan. 8, 2010

Category: Corruption - Views: 8559



Related

01.01.2011: Wikileaks: US officials pressured Karzai to remove former warlord Ismail Khan for “corruption and ineffectiveness”
29.12.2010: “Malign” Afghans Targeted
28.12.2010: Karzai Releasing Scores Of Drug Traffickers In Afghanistan, WikiLeaks Cables Show
30.11.2010: Karzai pardons criminals, drug dealers: WikiLeaks
14.11.2010: Afghan People Suffering Under Powerful Elite Tied To Karzai, U.S.
09.11.2010: Kabul drops graft charges against top aide
27.09.2010: U.S. Probes Karzai’s Kin
17.09.2010: Afghanistan’s Dark Cloud Has No Silver Lining
16.09.2010: For Kabul Voters, Corruption -- Up Close And Personal -- Is The Hot-Button Issue
14.09.2010: New Afghan Corruption Inquiries Frozen
09.09.2010: Afghan elite enjoys high life in Dubai
12.09.2010: Who made Kabul corrupt?
07.09.2010: Inside Corrupt-istan, a Loss of Faith in Leaders
27.08.2010: CIA pays officials around Karzai
25.08.2010: Key Karzai Aide in Corruption Inquiry Is Linked to C.I.A.
19.08.2010: Karzai aide part of wider investigation, Afghan officials say
12.08.2010: Afghanistan Money Probe Hits Close to the President
26.07.2010: Leaked Afghanistan files reveal corruption and drug-dealing
26.07.2010: Afghan MP’s Son Arrested for Prostitution Business and Human Trafficking in USA
20.07.2010: Corruption in Afghanistan Expanding at an Alarming Rate
17.07.2010: Poor grades to watchdog for Afghan reconstruction
06.07.2010: U.S. Funds Used to Buy Villas for Wealthy Afghans
08.07.2010: Survey of Afghans points to rampant corruption in government
05.07.2010: Afghanistan Corruption Twist
06.07.2010: Over USD4 bn in cash flies out of Kabul
21.06.2010: Warlords and Taliban receive millions of dollars from the USA
28.06.2010: U.S. officials say Karzai aides are derailing corruption cases involving elite
19.06.2010: World’s Mining Companies Covet Afghan Riches
09.06.2010: Garishly incongruous “poppy palaces” lure affluent Afghans
02.06.2010: Ahmad Wali Karzai: From waiter to “King of Kandahar”
19.05.2010: Unemployment forces Afghan youth to trek dangerous routes
18.05.2010: Afghanistan president’s brother, Ahmed Wali Karzai, under investigation
10.05.2010: Afghan warlords feed on US contracts, say critics
10.05.2010: AFGHANISTAN: Running on drugs, corruption and aid
07.05.2010: Thousands of acres of land illegal grabbed in north
03.05.2010: Karim Khalili and ministers accused of embezzling a million dollars
22.04.2010: Afghanistan War ‘A Waste of Blood and Treasure’
08.04.2010: Hamid Karzai frees Taliban commander kidnapper of British UN worker
30.03.2010: UN report: Afghans plagued by poverty, corruption
07.03.2010: Army launches investigation: Corrupt Afghans stealing millions from aid funds
25.02.2010: Officials puzzle over millions of dollars leaving Afghanistan by plane for Dubai

Latest

Most Viewed